Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Attack of the Davids!

I'm a big fan of Davids; from the Hoff Davids to the under-dog Davids. For the most part, I am a fan of Glenn Reynolds' An Army of Davids. For instance, in his chapter on music. I agree that P2P software really does facilitate creativity. The Internet fosters new talent and the music industry's fear of losing control is hampering the emergence of this new talent. I think the Japanese viewpoint on copyright is more amenable to our Internet age. In a country where Anime and Manga play a huge part in their economy and culture, fans have often taken their favorites and turned them into best sellers in their own right. This fan-fiction is a growing phenomenon with sales that often rival their originators and huge conventions throughout the country. The publishing houses (the Goliath) have decided not to persecute these fan-artists (Davids) for a variety of reasons. One of the biggest reasons is that they have realized that the abundance (or lack of) of fan fiction is an ideal indicator of how well their product is performing and conventions serve as great breeding ground for new artists.

Where the book began to lose me was the chapter on packs and herds. I grew weary about his views on individuals going after terrorists online.

However, Reynolds does make valid points. Just last night, Howard Dean spoke at a (sadly) sparsely attended event hosted by the NAACP and the College Dems. Among, of course, many other things, he was touting a new DNC program about neighborhoods. The goal of the DNC is to set up many local neighborhood organizations as they can - because people will listen better to a person they know, from their area. (As a recent canvassing newbie, I know that I was intimidated going into strange neighborhoods and telling people to vote.) Dean talked about they are trying to remove the top-down information system that persisted from the past. They use all these tools that Reynolds talks about in his section on horizontal communication...

No comments: